Never give up

July 19, 2020

     It seems impossibly cruel that we would lose both Reverend C.T. Vivian and Congressman John Lewis on the same day. During what feels like the darkest period in this country’s history, it is hard to imagine living in an America without these two moral exemplars. 

      Both men were tutored in the philosophy of nonviolent resistance by the Reverend James Lawson.  Both men were arrested multiple times. Both C.T. Vivian and John Lewis were nearly killed for the “crime” of standing up for the civil rights of Black people.  The famous photos of John Lewis being viciously beaten by a state trooper as he stood at the head of a phalanx of marchers on the Edmund Pettus Bridge led directly to the passage of the Voting Rights Act of 1965. Continue reading “Never give up”

The price of betrayal

July 13, 2020

     In a pair of rulings this past week, an unusual alliance of Supreme Court justices reaffirmed that we are a nation of laws not men.  In McGirt v. Oklahoma, the Court forced the United States and the State of Oklahoma to honor the treaties they made and comply with the laws they passed, when dealing with the rights of the Creek Nation.  In McGirt, the Court ruled that the State of Oklahoma had no jurisdiction to prosecute crimes committed by Native Americans on Native American territory. Conservative Justice Neil Gorsuch, citing the 1833 United States treaty with the Creek Nation, said that the question presented was whether the “land [the] treaties promised remained an Indian reservation…. Because Congress has not said otherwise, we hold the government to its word,” (Source:  McGirt v. Oklahoma, No. 18-9526, U.S., July 9, 2020).

      The McGirt opinion methodically details the many promises broken by the United States in the 187 years since the 1833 Treaty with the Creeks was signed, as well as how consistently the state of Oklahoma asserted jurisdiction over Native citizens in contravention of federal law.  In arguing against upholding the plain words of the statute and the Treaty, both the State of Oklahoma and the four dissenting Justices, urged the Court to look to custom, practice and the changed demographics of the State to grant Oklahoma power over the Creek Nation that it clearly does not have.  The Court declined, stating that to do so would be “the rule of the strong, not the rule of law,” (Source:  McGirt at 28).  This was a decisive victory in the struggle to get the United States to honor its obligations to Native Americans. Continue reading “The price of betrayal”

Independence Day 2020

July 6, 2020

    We wake up the morning after this year’s Independence Day weekend, hungover from a hollowed out, grim echo of Independence Days past.  The rapidly escalating surge of coronavirus cases in thirty-two states,  including California, Texas, Arizona and Florida made barbecues and beach parties the sole province of the reckless.  The rest of us were left grilling for two and suffering through amateur pyrotechnics full of sound and fury, but devoid of spectacle. The dark skies were a metaphor for our national mood.

    On this July 4th, all Americans were trapped within our borders, as a result of the gross mismanagement of this pandemic by a corrupt bully.  We watched with envy as Europeans opened their restaurants and cafes, while we remain unable to escape to even Canada or Mexico, (Source:  “Mexico closes U.S. border in Arizona to stop July 4th visitors, citing COVID-19 fears,” by Mitchell Willetts, Fort Worth Star-Telegram News, 7/5/20).  Thanks to Trump, the only thing America leads the world in is COVID-19 cases and deaths. Continue reading “Independence Day 2020”

The Lost Cause

June 30, 2020

     “Whoever, owing allegiance to the United States, levies war against them or adheres to their enemies, giving them aid and comfort within the United States or elsewhere, is guilty of treason,” (Source:  18 U.S.C.§2381).  When Trump was impeached, many of us said that blackmailing a beleaguered ally by withholding military aid to boost his own political fortunes was traitorous conduct.  When we pointed out that a weakened Ukraine helped Russia, our geopolitical foe, wags pointed out that we were not at war with Russia, so Trump’s alarming abdication of duty did not rise to the level of treason.  It was a shockingly low bar for the President of the United States, but every Republican save for Mitt “Black Lives Matter” Romney decided it was sufficient for Trump to remain in office.

      How do they explain Trump’s response to the alarming news that Russia was offering a bounty to Taliban forces for the murder of American troops?  Friday, the news broke that Trump has known of the Russian bounties since at least March and was given a menu of option for how to respond, (Source:  “Russia Secretly Offered Afghan Militants Bounties to Kill U.S.Troops, Intelligence Says,” by Charlie Savage, Eric Schmitt and Michael Schwirtz, The New York Times, 6/26/20).  Trump reacted by claiming ignorance and The New York Times responded by reporting that the intelligence was in the President’s Daily Brief in late February, even earlier than initially thought, (Source:  “Trump Got Written Briefing on Possible Russian Bounties in February, Officials Say,” by Charlie Savage, Eric Schmitt, Nicholas Fandos and Adam Goldman, The New York Times, 6/29/20).

      No amount of scrambling or spinning by Trump and his staff of inveterate professional liars can obscure the facts.  Trump, when confronted with reliable intelligence that Russia was paying for the murder of American troops did…nothing.

      It is hardly surprising.  Trump has never shown a shred of respect for the sacrifices made by American soldiers or a concern for the lives of any human beings. 126,161 dead Americans are the starkest testament to Trump’s deadly combination of amoral sociopathy and criminal negligence.  Faced with these damning revelations, Trump retweeted geriatric racists yelling “white power” from a golf cart and gun-toting wannabe militiamen in powder pink polos, rather than doing the only decent thing and resigning.

       Trump has never possessed a single quality required to be a decent President, or a decent human being, for that matter.  He is, and always has been, a vulgar, corrupt and racist bully; a one trick pony whose only cause was white supremacy.  It is a damning indictment of this country that Trump got any closer to the Oval Office than a White House tour.

       As the pandemic body count rises and more damning proof emerges that Trump has more loyalty to Russia than to the country he swore an oath to protect, it becomes clear why he wants to protect Confederate statues.  They were traitors too.

Little fires everywhere

     In the five days since Trump’s disastrous Tulsa rally, we have all been laughing at what an abject failure it was.  Trump has been mercilessly mocked for being duped by K-Pop fans, for the pitiful 6200 people in attendance, for the unhinged, rambling speech.  Buoyed by the strong showing by progressive candidates in Tuesday’s primaries, gloating over Biden’s widening lead in the polls, we feel as if victory is so close we can taste it.

      Yet, while we were dining out on schadenfreude, we were reaping the bitter harvest of the toxic seeds sown by Donald Trump. Yesterday the Senate confirmed Cory Wilson, the 200th federal judge appointed by Trump (Source:  “Senate confirms Trump’s 200th judicial nominee,” by Devan Cole and Ted Barrett, CNN.com, 6/24/20).  Wilson will serve on the Fifth Circuit, the appellate court with jurisdiction over Louisiana, Texas and Mississippi, home to 9 million Black and Latinx Americans.  Wilson is a 50 year old Mississippi lawyer and former state representative, who once called for the “complete and immediate reversal of Roe v. Wade.” Continue reading “Little fires everywhere”

We are the architects

June 17, 2020

      Toni Morrison famously said, “the function, the very serious function of racism is distraction. It keeps you from doing your work.” The unceasing onslaught of racist murders has distracted all 41 million Black Americans, who are forced, yet again, to concentrate all of our energy on just being allowed to live.  We are thrust, once again, into a familiar role, of an un-individuated mass, supplicating the powers that be to acknowledge our humanity.  In white Americans popular imagination, Black people exist as a binary— either noble and long suffering, or thugs.  There is no understanding of the human cost of requiring 41 million people, whose roots in this country predate the founding of the republic, to relitigate the question of whether we are American.

     People mistake their ignorance of Black achievement for its absence, failing to understand just how much they owe to the brilliance, persistence and resilience of Black people.  We have always had to literally provide both our brains and our bodies to garner greater freedom for the whole.The landmark decision holding that Title VII prohibits employment discrimination against LGBT people, handed down by the Supreme Court in Bostock v. Clayton County, 590 U.S. ___(S.Ct, 2020), would have been impossible if the 1963 March on Washington (and subsequent murder of four little Black girls in a Birmingham church) had not forced the hand of President Kennedy, and then President Johnson, to push for passage of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, (Source: “March on Washington for Jobs and Freedom, 1963, The Martin Luther King, Jr. Research and Education Institute, kinginstitute.stanford.edu ).

      Few people know, however, that the March on Washington was the brainchild of A. Philip Randolph and Bayard Rustin, pioneering Civil Rights leaders who originally planned a March on Washington in 1941 to protest segregation in the defense industries. To head off the March, FDR signed an executive order desegregating the defense industries, but left segregation in the armed forces intact, (Source:  “African-American threaten march on Washington, 1941,” Global Nonviolent Action Database, nvdatabase.swarthmore.edu).

      Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg is rightly celebrated as the “Thurgood Marshall of the women’s rights movement,” for her role in securing equal protection under the law for Americans, regardless of sex, but as RBG herself acknowledges, she relied on the doctrinal foundation built by the brilliant Dr. Pauli Murray, the queer Black lawyer, activist and minister, (Source: “The Dynamic Woman Who Shaped Ruth Bader Ginsburg,” by Meghan White, savingplaces.org).  Murray was a co-founder of the National Organization for Women with Betty Friedan and her scholarship was the basis not only for securing equal protection under the law for women, but for Black people as well.  Murray’s law professor, Spottswood Robinson, was part of the team that argued Brown vs. Board of Education.  Robinson used Murray’s law school paper outlining a basis for challenging Plessy v. Ferguson under the 13th and 14th Amendments, as a resource when developing the strategy in Brown, (Source: “The Many Lives of Pauli Murray,” by Kathryn Schulz, The New Yorker, 4/10/17).

     When Black people are not forced to put our bodies in the service of our beliefs; when we are not consumed with grief over the unending list of Black people who become famous not for how they lived, but for how they died, we can provide the theoretical and organizational foundation for making this a more perfect union.  The truth is, Black people are the architects, not just the foot soldiers, of this nation’s freedom movements.  So thank us, and let us do our work.

     

Talk is cheap

June 9, 2020


    In the two weeks since George Floyd’s murder, we’ve seen hundreds of thousands of people take to the streets to declare that “Black Lives Matter.”  There have been demonstrations in all 50 states and in international capitols like London, Paris and Berlin. Trump’s effort to silence dissent by stepping up a military presence, tear gassing peaceful protestors to clear a path for a ridiculous photo op, backfired spectacularly.  

   Protestors were emboldened, rather than cowed.  Alarmed former military brass went public with their dismay, most notably, former Defense Secretary Jim Mattis, who broke his monk-like vow of silence to pen a scathing takedown of Trump, (Source:  “James Mattis Denounces President Trump, Describes Him as a Threat to the Consitution,” By Jeffrey Goldberg, theatlantic.com, 6/3/20).  In his statement, Mattis said that “Equal Justice Under Law…is precisely what the protestors are demanding.”

       Friday morning, D.C. Mayor Muriel Bowser trolled Trump in an epic fashion when she commissioned “Black Lives Matter,” to be painted in giant yellow letters on 16th Street in front of The White House and renamed the street Black Lives Matter Plaza.  By Sunday, Mitt Romney (Mitt Romney!) was marching with protestors in front of The White House tweeting “Black Lives Matter.” Time will tell if this was a deliberate echo of his father George Romney’s principled support of civil rights or an early salvo in his 2024 presidential campaign. Continue reading “Talk is cheap”

The Fire Next Time

May 31, 2020


    The fires are real.  The fires are a metaphor.


      Around the country, cities are ablaze.  What started in Minneapolis has spread to Los Angeles,New York, Chicago, Atlanta, Seattle, Louisville and Portland, and countless cities too numerous to name.  In most cities, the protests and ensuing violence is not merely in solidarity with Minneapolis, but in response to the prevalence of police brutality in each city.

     Rumors have swirled that the instigators of the arson and vandalism were primarily white. Whether they were anarchists unwilling to defer to Black organizers, or white supremacists mobilized to discredit the protest, they have succeeded in changing the conversation from anger over the repeated brutalization and murder of Black people at the hands of the police, (Source:  “Black Organizers ‘Enraged’ by White Agitators ‘Here to F**k Sh*t Up,’” by Justin Glawe, Rachel Olding and Hunter Woodall, thedailybeast.com, 5/31/20).  Yet even if some Black protestors were involved in the vandalism and looting, it is the height of hypocrisy to condemn Black people for breaking the law by destroying property, when our lives are consistently destroyed under color of law with impunity. Continue reading “The Fire Next Time”

We can’t breathe

May 27, 2020

     Malls are closed.  Offices are closed.  Beaches are closed, but racism never takes a day off.  By now, millions have seen the video filmed by African-American birder and New York Audubon Society board member, Christian Cooper.  In it, “Entitled Amy” reacts to his request that she obey the law and leash her dog while walking Central Park’s Ramble by getting in his face to say that she was going to call the police and tell them that an African- American man was threatening her and her dog.  In the ensuing call, Amy’s voice rises and becomes increasingly frantic in an effort to convey the impression that she is in danger, (Source:  “Amy Cooper’s 911 call is part of an all-too-familiar pattern,” by Anna North, Vox.com, 5/26/20).

    Fortunately for Christian Cooper, the police did not show up with guns drawn and his quick thinking led Amy to suffer actual consequences for her actions, losing her dog and her job within 24 hours. It’s unclear whether she has learned anything, given her complaint to CNN that “her life is being destroyed,” with that passive voice doing the heavy lifting of evading culpability.  Amy is desperately trying to reconstruct her image as a person who is “not racist”, rather than confronting the fact that, without thinking, she weaponized her whiteness to try to harm a Black man because she was annoyed.

      This is the danger.  Far too many self-professed white liberals and progressives won’t hesitate to wield their privilege to the detriment of Black people.  Black people know this and deep down, white people do too. It may not be in as extreme a manner as “Entitled Amy,” but we’ve seen it play out in myriad ways.  Even when white people don’t call the police, they take it on themselves to be the police— to question Black presence in what they deem to be  white spaces.  That is what awaits those who are lucky enough to successfully navigate school systems and other institutions that are indifferent at best and hostile at worst to the fates of Black people.  We live with the knowledge that we can be challenged on a whim in our sleepy suburban hamlets or tony urban high rises.  Our sons and daughters, who we’ve painstakingly shielded and guided, can be brutalized by the cops for the crime of being young and unruly.  Even when the cops are fired, it doesn’t heal the psychological scars our children should never have to bear. Yet we are the lucky ones.  At least we are alive.

       Just as we were relishing Christian Cooper’s karmic victory, we saw the sickening video of George Floyd being murdered in Minneapolis.  A gentle man who “fit the description” of someone suspected of the nonviolent crime of forgery was killed by a cop who ground his knee into George Floyd’s neck for nine minutes as he pleaded for his life.  Three other cops stood by passively and watched their fellow officer calmly murder George Floyd in cold blood, (Source:  “4 Minneapolis cops fired after video shows one kneeling on neck of black man who,later died,” by Ray Sanchez, Joe Sutton and Artemis Moshtaghian, CNN.com, 5/26/20).

     We tweet, we plead, we protest, we litigate, but little changes.  Black people are tired. And scared. And pissed.  We have one question for those of you who call yourselves allies. What are you going to do? Because we can’t breathe.

R.I.P. George Floyd

R.I.P. Breonna Taylor

R.I.P. Ahmaud Arbery

Wild, Wild West

May 21, 2020


     After two months in lockdown, we are bored. The sameness of the days, and the inability to gather with anyone outside of our immediate household has us antsy and irritable. Yet, in our haste to emerge from quarantine, some ugly truths are being revealed.  

      Despite scientific evidence that wearing a mask will stop the spread of the coronavirus, thousands of Americans, like petulant children, refuse to do so.  They blithely venture out unmasked to malls and restaurants, breathing with impunity on the masked workers who serve them, heedless of the harm they’re inflicting on others.   Some have reacted violently to the suggestion that they can’t enter an establishment without wearing a mask.  These people confuse lack of responsibility for freedom.  They demand the “right” to do what they want, regardless of who it harms.  Who can blame them, though, when the tone is set from the top. Continue reading “Wild, Wild West”